Theories

These are the theories made by the players through out the campaigns and one-shots.

Sincere

 * Bob the Barbarian, died by being stabbed in the penis (Inconclusive)
 * Bob the Barbarian, survived (Inconclusive)

Sincere

 * Lyra is not Nightshade's Kid but a member of his old organisation (True)
 * Lyra turned out to be Nightshade's master, Mitsu
 * Loki, Mistu and Nightshade are from the same organisation (True)
 * Nightshade, Mistu and Loki are from the Shadow Thieves.


 * Mei was burning Churches along the Swordcoast for Bane (False)
 * Churches were burned by Illuminator Hyperion for an unknown group.
 * Mei follows a god she refers to as "Bane" but Could be Patron of Stories mentioned in Excerpt XV
 * Billy was burning churches along the Swordcoast (False)
 * Churches were burned by Illuminator Hyperion for an unknown group
 * Loki is involved with the Zhentarim (Inconclusive)
 * Hi'edad is lying about her skin condition (false)
 * She is a vampire and has flesh that burn in sunlight
 * Snigbat will be a BBEG (possibly)
 * Apollo, Billy, Rat-King are all Clones of the same person (Inconclusive)
 * Giants hired the Great Worm Tribe to enter the Eye of the All-father Temple (False)
 * The Great Worm Tribe entered the temple to look for Noori, who was captured by ice spiders in the temple
 * The Axe of Thyrm was in the crack in the wall of the temple (False)
 * The crack led to an Ice Spider Nest
 * The Axe was in the dinning hall
 * Noori hated Wormblood (True)
 * Wormblood killed the old chief of the tribe, Noori's father and took Noori as his mate.
 * She was angry at HD for stealing her kill
 * Fenris is actually the Ancient Black Dragon Wyrm Iyrauroth (Inconclusive)
 * Gon made Hovel the Ratking's Mask (Inconclusive)
 * Ben is the byproduct for a stronger being's resurrection (Inconclusive)


 * Toyere and the Dead Rats were connected to Hovel (True)
 * Confirmed by the sleep deprived DM

Satire

 * Ben is Nightshade (Inconclusive) 
 * Ben is Billy (False)
 * Billy was turned into Gon and has no memories of being billy
 * Ben sunk Northkeep (Inconclusive)
 * Apollo is just a Billy goat someone cast polymorph on (Inconclusive)
 * Lox killed Billy (False)
 * Billy was turned into Gon and has no memories of being billy
 * Yen sold his chromosomes instead of his soul to the Archfey (Inconclusive)
 * Yen killed his parents, which is why he is avoiding Phandalin (Inconclusive)
 * The Pirate Lords of Luskan can use Haki (Probably)
 * Fifth High Captain Rethnor and his cook Ulmragha Kaal both seemed to have unusually high awareness of their surroundings.
 * Three members of the Ship Rethnor have also displayed devil fruit like abilities:
 * Captain Rethnor - Barrier creation paramecia
 * Ulmragha Kaal - Giant golden eagle zoan
 * Navigator Knock-Knock - Mist logia
 * Al killed everyone in the Tranquil Caves and is trying to kill Loki (Inconclusive)
 * Hoid was so annoyed by Ben he reached back across time and space, broke the Ordning himself, and planted the idea of that you guys were some sort of chosen group in Zephy's head (Inconclusive)
 * Hi'edad is actually nightshades wife, who got taken hostage by the orcs and then saved by orc from Neverwinter (false)
 * She is the adopted daughter of Toytere of the Dead rats
 * Hi'edad is the new Rat-King (Inconclusive)
 * Dia is a slave in the City of Coin (Inconclusive)
 * Loki is shagging Dia (Inconclusive)
 * Yen's lost two years were off him pretending to be a guy named "Billy"(Inconclusive)
 * The Sunweavers committed war crimes (True)
 * Lucien killed unarmed drow after the war in Excerpt XXIV
 * Gon was the Rat King (Inconclusive)
 * HD and Al are half-siblings (Inconclusive)

Predictions

 * RatKing wears/wore an Obito Mask
 * Almond accidentally kills Ilmater
 * Loki kills Ilmater on purpose
 * Ben is a failed Philosopher Stone
 * Ben will end up eternally fighting snigbat in one way or other
 * Ben dies at the end of his quest
 * Yen kills Iymrith, Illuminator and the Archfey
 * Lox kills Apollo
 * HD gets crowned the Ratking
 * HD gets killed by Noori during their re-match (Noori lost the first fight and is waiting for HD to return for the rematch)
 * Almond becomes the Champion of Ilmater (Mythill became the champion after almond gave him the Shroud)
 * Hyperion is creating clones of himself.
 * Billy was Hovel the Rat King.